Choose dress or sport, then the case size for your wrist, the metal and the papers
First choose between a dress watch and a sport watch. The Datejust and the Day-Date dress up, and the Submariner and the GMT-Master II are made for the water and the airport. The Datejust is the one our buyers choose most. Take the 41 on a broad wrist. A slim wrist wears the 36. Every watch here is pre-owned and final sale, so ask the desk everything before you pay.
The model: men's Rolex Datejust, Day-Date, Submariner or GMT-Master II
Choose dress or sport before you look at dials. The Datejust and the gold Day-Date are the dress watches, and most men who buy a Rolex from us take one of the two. The Submariner is the dive watch, with a turning bezel to time the dive. The GMT-Master II reads a second time zone off its 24-hour bezel, and the Sky-Dweller adds an annual calendar. Buy the one you will wear on a Tuesday.
Wrist size: 36 mm or 41 mm Rolex for a man
Measure your wrist with a strip of paper before you pick a case. Under seven inches, the 36 sits flat and looks right. From seven inches up, go to the 41, which fills the wrist the way a modern watch does. The 40 mm sport models wear close to it. Do not write the 36 off as small. More of our buyers chose it than any other size. The Sky-Dweller and the Sea-Dweller run bigger still and want a broad wrist.
The metal: steel, two-tone or 18K gold men's Rolex
Start with steel if the watch will go everywhere with you. Rolex calls it Oystersteel, and the steel watches sit on our full Rolex page, since this page holds two-tone and solid gold. Two-tone puts yellow gold or Everose, Rolex's rose gold, on the bezel and the center links. Solid 18K gold is mostly the Day-Date, which Rolex never makes in steel. The five-link Jubilee is the dressier bracelet and the flat Oyster the tougher one.
Card and box: men's Rolex with papers, or the watch alone
Read the card-and-papers block in the description before you fall for the dial. Close to half of the watches for sale still have their Rolex card or papers. Others are sold as the watch alone, and on nearly every listing the box is an extra you add. The card carries the serial and the dealer who first sold the watch, a paper trail rather than proof. Our watch team inspects every watch in person before it is listed, card or no card. Keep the card safe, because the next buyer will ask for it.
Final sale: buying a pre-owned men's Rolex on 47th Street
Every Rolex here is final sale, because the store's refund policy names watches among the items it will not take back. So settle every doubt before you pay. Confirm the reference and the year on the card in the live chat, where you can also ask whether we size the bracelet before it ships; texts to 212-872-9692 reach a person from 10 AM ET. A watch marked sold out cannot be ordered online, so ask the desk about that one. For a watch we do not show, send the desk the model and the dial, and we look for it through the trade. In-stock watches ship tracked, usually in two to five business days.